Catherine StewartMelbourne Flower Show 2018 – analysis & trends

I again made my annual trip to Melbourne for the Melbourne Flower and Garden Show 2018. As I’m a horticultural out-of-towner and a landscape/garden design specialist, I spend most of my time studying and analysing the big show gardens (as well as the boutique and student gardens). So what were this year’s standouts, disappointments and trends?

Australian Case Study Garden. Design e-ga. MIFGS 2018

Australian Case Study Garden. Design e-ga. MIFGS 2018

 

Gold and Best in Show – Australian Case Study Garden – Design E-GA

Eckersley Garden Architecture (E-GA) again combined with major sponsors Australian House and Garden magazine in a large show garden, although the designers this year were a trio of its younger designers: Josh Cocks, Rupert Baynes-Williamns and Clare Mackarness. The ‘Australian Case Study Garden‘, which also celebrates AH&G’s 70 years in publication, represents the designers’ view of “true Australian style”, reflecting both European gardening heritage and migrant influences.

Australian Case Study Garden. Design e-ga. MIFGS 2018

 

I agree that this was a very well-designed contemporary garden with energetic and innovative planting combinations and, overall, an excellent result from a three-person design collaboration; not an easy way to design a MIFGS garden. But I couldn’t see much evidence of those ethnic influences, or the plants and garden fashions of the past 70 years that I read were part of the brief. Maybe it’s the advantage of having lived and gardened through those decades variously featuring standard iceberg roses, Grevillea ‘Robin Gordon’ or buxus hedges, but most of the plant material looked like more recent fashions and cultivars to me. I’m also not convinced by the collection of ‘Aussie’ items scattered through the garden – a Hills Hoist, cricket bat and stumps, eski and board shorts. A bit too obvious and tokenistic I thought. Maybe I’ve lost my sense of fun! However I did really like the brick fireplace/chimney – that stack bond style made a strong central focal point and is very evocative of the early 1960s.

 

GOLD Medal and People’s Choice- Inspired by Time garden, design by Orisis Shanghai Ltd

I hardly know where to begin with this garden, except to say that I found it to be one of the most ghastly gardens I’ve ever seen at MIFGS. Evidently that reveals my cultural bias towards a different aesthetic, as its confounding and depressing award of a Gold Medal and selection as People’s Choice winner goes to prove that I swim against the tide on this one.

Inspired by Time. Design Orisis Shanghai Ltd

Inspired by Time. Design Orisis Shanghai Ltd

 

I think it was confused, cluttered and looked like someone had been through a catalogue of Chinese garden ideas and decided that they had to have them all. There was striped paving, plain paving, stepping stones, pebbles and black water ponds, a stone-stacked wall, cor-ten cut screen panel, a different cor-ten screen in another design, painted timber slat pergola, bamboo screen, 2 x three-part painted glass screens, cor-ten wall water feature with yet another different laser-cut design, traditional black rounded tiles…and that’s before we even start listing the added decorative sculptures, rocks, pots, lanterns, painted tree, rustic tools AND highly coloured planting. If it had a wow factor, it was wow in a totally gob-smacked way that this design is now MIFGS Gold standard.

Inspired by Time. Design Orisis Shanghai Ltd

 

The construction and finish of the garden were indeed excellent, but surely good design is the most important thing in show garden judging?

I also overheard several show-goers saying what a lovely Japanese garden it was, which was even more depressing and must have sent the Japanese landscaping team at the nearby the Unity garden into a (quietly restrained) frenzy.

 

An inspirational garden design – Unity garden, design Ross Uebergang and Yousuke Yamaguchi.

This lets me segue into a quick discussion about a garden that didn’t win any medal – the Unity garden, designed as a cross-cultural experiment by Melburnian Ross Uebergang with Japanese designer Yousuke Yamaguchi.

Unity garden, design Ross Uebergang and Yousuke Yamaguchi

 

When I asked several designers I met at the show which was the garden they liked the most, their responses were unanimous – the Unity garden. In fact one said,

“Thank goodness for the Unity garden pushing some boundaries!”

 

Unity garden, design Ross Uebergang and Yousuke Yamaguchi

Unity garden, design Ross Uebergang and Yousuke Yamaguchi

 

I’m not saying that this garden deserved a medal as the construction standard was not good enough for that. But it makes me think that there could be a discretionary MIFGS award for ‘Design Vision’ which rewards those designers who do want to push design boundaries and experiment with new and untried materials and unconventional planting ideas. Taking those risks will only occasionally pay off in the conventional medal sense, but full marks from me to Ross and Yousuke for giving it a go. I loved the crackling dryness of the cut foliage used as planting and the surprisingly delicate rammed earth curved screens (now who but Ross would choose a heavy and difficult material like clay for that purpose). It also really fulfilled its brief with its combination of Japanese aesthetic and very Australian materials and plants.

 


Melbourne Flower and Garden Show 2018 trends:

Naturalistic design

Although there were a couple of exceptions, most of the MIFGS 2018 gardens favoured an informal design style without strong ground plane shapes or straight lines. Swathes of multi-species planting, naturalistic water features, boulders, and stained or even unfinished timber were common. Colour palettes were also subdued and autumnal, with browns and greys, rusty tones, combined with cream, purple and rusty orange. Planting combinations nearly all had grasses, an obvious choice for foliage impact in late summer, as well as perennials with small flowers. Pruning was subtle, with just a bit of shaping here and here to give shrubs a stronger rounded form.

Aquascape Harmony garden designed by Meg Geary and Ben Harris

Aquascape Harmony garden designed by Meg Geary and Ben Harris

 

The Aquascape Harmony garden (BRONZE Award) designed by Meg Geary (MG Gardens) and Ben Harris (Ben Harris Gardens) and the Living Garden (SILVER Award) by STEM Landscape Architecture and Design were standout examples, with naturalistic water courses so expertly designed and constructed that you’d swear they were cut out of the bush somewhere and craned in.

Living Garden MIFGS 2018. Design STEM Landscape Architecture and Design

 

More Australian plants but also non-apartheid planting schemes

Emmaline Bowman’s (STEM Landscape Architecture and Design) native planting in the Living Garden was exquisite and the garden aptly rewarded with a SILVER medal. Her knowledge of local plants and her combinations continue to mature and her planting combos would have to turn even the most hardened ‘exoticophile’ into a native plant enthusiast.

Living Garden MIFGS 2018. Design STEM Landscape Architecture and Design

 

Even better was seeing more gardens with Australian plants and their exotic cousins playing very happily together, each contributing to a satisfying whole. A bit of a metaphor for what we’d like for our whole country.

I’m so over of the plant apartheid practised in Australia which requires that gardens are either exotic, or native, but never both. The segregation starts in the plant nurseries with that stupid ‘Native Plants’ section and continues through too many designers’ work. They’re all just plants, and many so-called ‘native plants’ are native only to the nursery in which those cultivars were bred, as they don’t exist anywhere naturally, and many others are as botanically different between east coast and west as they are from nearby other countries.

Australian Case Study Garden. Design E-GA.
I can count at least 7 different native plant species in this garden

 

At last in MIFGS 2018 we saw several designers choosing plants based on much more important criteria – their texture, form, foliage colour, flowers and durability, rather than their origin. The results were spectacular and, I think, some of the most interesting plant combos we’ve seen at this show to date (Phillip Withers’ gardens excepted!). It also reflects much more what happens in most suburban gardens as gardeners usually care little about being purists one way or the other and are just as likely to impulse buy a fan flower for their garden as a campanula.

Where the mix had probably been at best 80-20 exotic to native in recent years, in the MIFGS 2018 gardens, designers are now choosing a much broader palette of Australian plants to add to this glorious mix. There is still more selective breeding needed to get a wide enough range of Australian plants that will thrive in ordinary gardens to have 50-50 native-exotic gardens but I hope we’re on the cusp.

 

Water features

Goodness knows why any designer wants to include a water feature in a MIFGS show garden. They are notoriously difficult to install in these ‘no dig’ gardens on sloping sites and invariably leak. This predicament is usually indicated by tell-tale hoses draped surreptitiously over one edge that keep them filling as fast as they drip away. At least those towering Carlton Gardens plane trees must be getting a good watering!

But 2018 saw most designers ready to take on the risk so I’m guessing they see it as a current garden must-have. And many of these water features were exceptionally good quality. It takes a seasoned expert to be able to place stones so convincingly. The water courses made by MG Gardens and Ben Harris Gardens (Aquascape Harmony Garden – BRONZE Award), STEM Landscape Architecture (Living Garden – SILVER Award) were spectacular (scroll back up for those photos), and MIFGS newcomer Ben Hutchinson’s Grow Together was also charming.

Grow Together. Design Ben Hutchinson

 

Good rock work needs to be combined with planting that adds to, rather than covers up the stones, so that the solidity and textural contrasts of each material complement rather than dominate the other. Water-living plants are harder to do well than land-growing plants, and it is here that real expertise shines.

 

Stained timber

In theme with this year’s naturalistic designs, most timber was stained rather than painted.

 

 

Fire bowls, pits and places

I know there are those who think that backyard fire bowls and fireplaces are so last Thursday, but I heartily disagree. Have they never raised a teenager? Far more useful and cost effective than a swimming pool, a backyard fire will keep those young pyromaniacs safely entertained for hours. I think that a firebowl is a brilliant garden accessory as, unlike a firepit, you can wheel/drag them into the most wind-protected spot on the day. There were some really gorgeous ones scatted through the MIFGS 2018 stalls, mostly rusting steel but then that does work well with timber.

Rusting steel fire bowl in Grow Together. Design Ben Hutchinson

 

Ornamentation – when too much is barely enough

What is it with landscape designers these days and adding stuff, more stuff and yet more stuff into their gardens? It’s long been one of my main criticisms of the Achievable student gardens but this year they showed restraint and the main show gardens went all out.

Yes, there have been overly spartan and minimalist periods when gardens were all smooth clean lines and there was barely an interesting sculpture but we seem to be in an opposite phase and I can’t say I like it. Several of the MIFGS 2018 show gardens had so many focal points and decorative touches – wall art, several different ‘floor’ treatments, paving patterns, sculptures, nice boulders, fancy planters, several types of furniture, cushions, throws, lights, candles, glasses and various bits and bobs that it made the eyes and head dizzy. And all of that on top of complex and often colourful planting.

I remembered the satisfying simplicity of Ian Barker’s truly wonderful ‘Crossroads’  MIFGS garden from 2015 (one of the best MIFGS show gardens there has ever been) where the complex planting was all the decoration needed, but which I believe was marked down by the judges for lacking other ornamentation. Good garden design doesn’t need baubles for babies. Unfortunately it seems that MIFGS judges like and reward this excessive and distracting ornamentation. The prime offender in 2018 was, of course, the Orisis garden – but I’ve discussed that above.

 

SQUARE 1 MIFGS 2018. Design Candeo Design

 

Brent Reid of Candeo bucked that overdecorated trend with his Square 1 garden, beautifully constructed by those show garden masters, Semken Landscaping. I  really liked Brent’s garden. There’s something so refreshing about creamy-white and rich greens quietly singing together. Brent is a very good plantsman and the undulating waves of form and textural contrasts through the foliage planting, occasionally punctuated with an erupting aloe or a speckle of white flowers, was exquisite. I loved the way there were dense plants everywhere, including under seats and tables – it gave the impression that the garden spaces were carved out of a block of three-dimensional greenery. Look at that long and solid-looking seat, seemingly floating on a sea of lush foliage! Brent also added a hint of canopy with a light pergola. This was something I missed in many of the other gardens which felt too open to the sky.

SQUARE 1 MIFGS 2018. Design Candeo Design

 

Really, really rusty

I can’t complete a MIFGS round-up without commenting on the dominance of cor-ten (rusting) steel in the garden ornaments for sale at the show. I lost count of the rusty-look firebowls, birds, archways, wall art, screens and general doo-dads. Although I like the colour and patina of this material, I think that the current pervasiveness will make it date very quickly.

 

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nunc metus urna, malesuada dictum tincidunt quis, malesuada non dolor. Etiam dapibus vulputate massa id bibendum. Aliquam accumsan a diam sit amet tempor. Aliquam erat volutpat. In tincidunt fermentum accumsan. Morbi semper arcu lectus. Curabitur molestie elit et nisi feugiat molestie. Cras in lorem ultricies metus tincidunt viverra.

Cras dui sem, varius nec massa vulputate, accumsan blandit lacus. Nam faucibus volutpat lobortis. Aliquam aliquet felis at ligula scelerisque rhoncus. Maecenas elementum pharetra risus nec blandit. Morbi ut aliquet lectus, et bibendum neque. Donec egestas mauris non dolor bibendum, sed mattis odio porta. Donec id sem quis dolor suscipit malesuada sed vitae est.

Like this post? Why not share it with a friend?


Catherine Stewart

About Catherine Stewart

Award-winning garden journalist, blogger and photographer; writer for garden magazines and co-author of 'Waterwise Gardening'; landscape designer turned landscape design judge and critic; compulsive networker and lover of generally putting fingers in lots of pies. Particularly mud pies. Original creator of GardenDrum. South Coast NSW.

6 thoughts on “Melbourne Flower Show 2018 – analysis & trends

  1. Hi Catherine,
    It was great to catch up (all but briefly) at the show. Always nice to see you and chat.
    I am glad you liked our garden and I appreciate the kind words. I also appreciate the fact you understood the reservation it took to design that garden. When you have good plants and confidence in them it gives you the luxury to leave other things out.
    I do really think this years show was a huge positive. It seemed a little like a changing of the guard. We had 5 first time Show Garden designers, 3 (including 1 collab of 2 boutique garden designers) of which have come through the Student Garden/Boutique Garden ranks and stepped up to do a show garden. Ben Hutchinson did an amazing job for his first time putting his show garden together on a 5 week timeline after a designer pulled out last minute.
    As designers we definitely need to keep pushing the envelope and evolving, for ourselves, the industry and the show. Funny enough we never know what other people are taking to the show until we all get there and start building so sometimes colours and materials can look a little similar.
    All in all, if this is the next generation of the landscape design industry I think we are in some good hands… if we all keep pushing forward of course. Which I know we will!!
    I certainly hope to see you at the show again next year.
    Kind regards
    Brent

  2. Helen on said:

    Insightful, fearlessly honest and fascinating to read as always, Catherine. I totally agree about the Orisis garden and was shocked that it was People’s Choice. How disappointing. MIFGS is certainly a great event though, in a beautiful location, and thoroughly enjoyable.Thanks to all the brave and hard-working designers, growers and suppliers who take part.

  3. Yes, Helen, I stood there and looked at the Orisis garden and its gold award and felt that our understanding of good garden design had sunk to a new low.
    As far as Peoples Choice goes, I think that when people see a garden in this rather 2-dimensional display form where they are ranged along one presentation side only, they don’t think about well-designed spaces or being in a garden but instead like to look at baubles, which this garden satisfied aplenty.

  4. Elle on said:

    I wouldn’t take much notice of the People’s Choice awards this year. It was done online so anyone in the world could vote – yes even people in China! I think most of the voting come from social media posts rather than people who actually visited the gardens. Also, you could vote multiple times with the same email. If the show organisers want to get serious about People’s Choice, I think it should be limited to those who visit the show (so you can do a fairer comparison) and allow only 1 vote per legitimate email.

  5. Isobel on said:

    Catherine, you speak the truth as usual! I would feel most at home in the Australian Case Study Garden, despite the fact that it was a bit hit and miss. Inspired By Time, however, was far from inspirational – what were they thinking??

  6. Catherine on said:

    I’m not sure whether you mean the designers of Inspired By Time, or the judges who awarded it Gold, but I’d agree with you either way.

Feel free to comment (no need to register)
For help to identify a plant, find a gardening product or for general gardening advice, please use the Gardening HELP page.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.